Staten Island Trip and Fall Lawyers

If you sustained serious injuries due to hazardous property conditions on Staten Island or anywhere in New York, an experienced Staten Island trip and fall lawyer at Minchew & Santner, LLP can help. With over 38 years of combined litigation experience, we hold negligent property owners, commercial businesses, and landlords accountable to secure full compensation for your medical bills, lost wages, and pain and suffering.

Call (718) 727-7700 for a Free Consultation

★★★★★ 5.0 Rating on Google — “I got a settlement that was quick and easy. Very professional.” — Jerry Q.

Choosing a Trip and Fall Lawyer in Staten Island

Trip and fall and slip and fall accidents occur suddenly, leaving victims with life-altering injuries ranging from broken bones and torn ligaments to spinal trauma and traumatic brain injuries (TBI). Under New York premises liability law, property owners, commercial tenants, and managing agents have a strict legal obligation to maintain reasonably safe conditions for visitors, tenants, and pedestrians.

Establishing Liability in New York Premises Liability Claims

To establish legal liability in a New York trip and fall or slip and fall lawsuit, your legal team must prove four core elements:

  1. Dangerous Condition: A hazardous or defective condition existed on the property (e.g., raised sidewalk flags, missing or broken handrails, unlit stairwells, wet floors, or uneven pavement).
  2. Legal Duty: The property owner, commercial tenant, or managing agent owed a legal duty to maintain the area where you fell.
  3. Breach of Duty: The owner failed to repair the hazard, clear snow or ice within a reasonable time, or post adequate warning signs.
  4. Causation & Damages: The dangerous condition directly caused your fall and resulting physical and financial injuries.

Proving “Notice” of the Hazardous Condition

Under New York law, property owners are not automatically liable simply because an accident happened on their premises. You must prove that the owner or commercial tenant had notice of the hazardous condition, which is established in one of three ways:

1. Creation of the Condition

If the owner, tenant, or their employee directly creates the hazard, notice is legally established without needing to prove how long the condition existed. For example, if a store employee mops an aisle without placing warning cones, or a contractor performs a defective sidewalk patch that leaves a tripping lip, the defendant created the hazard.

2. Actual Notice

You can prove actual notice by showing that the property owner or manager was explicitly informed of the hazardous condition prior to your fall. This can be established through:

  • Written complaints, 311 records, or emails sent to building management.
  • Prior verbal warnings from tenants, employees, or patrons.
  • Evidence of prior, inadequate repair attempts or NYC Department of Buildings (DOB) violations.

3. Constructive Notice

Constructive notice applies when a hazard was visible, apparent, and existed for a sufficient length of time prior to the accident that a reasonable property owner should have discovered and corrected it (see Gordon v. American Museum of Natural History). We establish constructive notice through surveillance footage, witness testimony, inspection logs, and meteorological data.

Special Premises Liability Rules in New York

Sidewalk Accidents (NYC Administrative Code § 7-210)

If you tripped and fell on a public sidewalk on Staten Island—whether along Hylan Boulevard, Richmond Avenue, Victory Boulevard, Forest Avenue, or a residential street—determining who is legally responsible depends on the adjoining property:

  • Commercial and Multi-Family Properties: Under NYC Administrative Code § 7-210, owners of commercial properties and residential buildings with four or more units are strictly liable for injuries caused by their failure to maintain adjoining sidewalks, including cracked concrete, uneven flags, tree-root uplift, and failure to clear snow and ice.
  • One-, Two-, and Three-Family Homes: The City of New York generally remains liable for sidewalk trip and falls adjoining owner-occupied 1-, 2-, or 3-family homes, provided the property is used exclusively for residential purposes.

Stairwell & Apartment Building Accidents (Multiple Dwelling Law § 52 & § 78)

Under New York Multiple Dwelling Law § 78, owners of apartment buildings have a non-delegable duty to keep every part of the building—including roofs, lobbies, interior stairs, exterior steps, and common hallways—in good repair. When falls happen on stairs, building code violations involving defective and missing apartment handrails or missing handrails on exterior stairs provide powerful evidence of landlord negligence.

Commercial Waivers & Other Property Hazards

Commercial gyms, event venues, and property managers often try to avoid responsibility by pointing to liability waivers signed by visitors. Under New York General Obligations Law § 5-326, many exculpatory clauses and liability waivers are void and unenforceable as against public policy. Our firm also handles premises claims involving dog bites and animal attacks on residential and commercial properties.

Suing a Government Entity: The Strict 90-Day Notice of Claim Rule

If you tripped and fell on a public sidewalk adjoining a government building, in a NYC park, on a Staten Island Ferry terminal walkway, or on property owned by the City